The Federal High Court sitting in Abuja has nullified the substitution of former Benue State Governor, Gabriel Suswam, and affirmed him as the duly elected candidate of the All Progressives Congress for the Benue North-East Senatorial District ahead of the 2027 general elections. Delivering a landmark judgment on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, Justice Inyang Ekwo sacked incumbent Senator Emmanuel Udende as the party’s flagbearer and ordered both the ruling party and the Independent National Electoral Commission to recognize Suswam as the legitimate nominee.
The decisive ruling brings an end to a fiercely contested pre-election legal battle initiated by Suswam through suit number FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026. In the originating summons filed against the All Progressives Congress, Senator Emmanuel Udende, and the Independent National Electoral Commission, the former governor challenged the party’s decision to forward Udende’s name to the electoral umpire despite Suswam having emerged victorious at the party’s primary election.
Before delving into the substantive merits of the case, Justice Ekwo dismissed the preliminary objections raised by the defendants seeking to terminate the suit on technical grounds, ruling that the objections lacked merit.
Moving to the core dispute, the court examined official records from the primary election conducted on May 18, 2026, where the APC National Assembly Primary Election Committee declared Suswam the winner after he polled a commanding 131,083 votes against Udende’s 1,364 votes.
Despite that overwhelming margin of victory at the primary polls, the leadership of the All Progressives Congress subsequently transmitted Udende’s name to the Independent National Electoral Commission as its senatorial candidate for the 2027 elections.
Aggrieved by the move, Suswam, represented by his legal team led by Jibrin Okutepa, Senior Advocate of Nigeria, approached the Federal High Court to determine whether a political party can lawfully substitute a validly nominated primary winner without satisfying the strict conditions stipulated under the Electoral Act and the party’s own constitution and guidelines.
A pivotal turning point during the proceedings occurred when the Independent National Electoral Commission distanced itself from the party’s substitution. Appearing for the electoral body, counsel Anthony Malik, Senior Advocate of Nigeria, informed the court that official monitoring reports compiled by INEC officials who observed the May 18 exercise confirmed unequivocally that Gabriel Suswam won the primary election, urging the court to dispense justice in accordance with the law.
In resolving all substantive issues in favour of the plaintiff, Justice Ekwo held that the All Progressives Congress acted outside the bounds of the Electoral Act by attempting to discard the outcome of its own primary election without any lawful justification. Consequently, the court granted all the reliefs sought by Suswam, nullifying the submission of Udende’s name and compelling the party and INEC to immediately accord Suswam full recognition as the authentic APC senatorial candidate for Benue North-East.
The judgment sets the stage for a high-stakes political rematch in Benue North-East as the 2027 general elections draw closer. Suswam and Udende previously clashed for the same senatorial seat during the 2023 election cycle—a contest that saw Udende eventually retain the seat following an appellate court ruling in November 2023.
With the Federal High Court now restoring Suswam’s mandate within the ruling party, political observers across Benue State and the North-Central zone anticipate intense realignment within the Benue APC chapter ahead of the 2027 polls
