Former Kogi West Senator, Dino Melaye, has denied making any comments about the health of Federal High Court judge, Justice Peter Lifu, following remarks by elder statesman Buba Galadima linking him to discussions surrounding the judge’s reported illness.
Melaye, in a statement posted on his X account on Saturday, expressed surprise that Galadima mentioned his name while criticising members of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) over their alleged reaction to reports of the judge’s health condition.
The former lawmaker insisted that he had never made any statement concerning Lifu’s health, accusing Galadima of wrongly associating him with the controversy.
“I was extremely shocked to hear that Alhaji Buba Galadima mentioned that I made comments on Justice Lifu’s health. It is most unfortunate because I never made any comment on Justice Lifu’s health,” Melaye wrote.
He subsequently directed a personal attack at Galadima, suggesting that age was affecting the elder statesman’s recollection of events.
“Old age must be catching up with Buba Galadima. Now I know you can’t cure old age, you can only manage it,” he added.
The exchange followed comments made by Galadima, a chieftain of the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC), during an interview on African Independent Television (AIT) on Wednesday.
Galadima had criticised some ADC members over what he described as their reported celebration of the illness of Justice Lifu, who recently delivered a judgment against the opposition party in its leadership dispute.
During the interview, Galadima referred to information that the ADC had obtained a certified true copy of the judgment and mentioned Melaye while discussing the party’s reaction to reports about the judge’s health.
He said he had heard that some ADC members were celebrating the reported illness of the judge and the possibility that he might be taken abroad for medical treatment.
“You know there was a judgment against ADC, isn’t it? Yes. And I’ve just heard you read something that Dino Melaye said,” Galadima stated.
He continued: “They’ve got a true certified copy of the judgment, and I know some ADC people are jumping up and down that the judge (Peter Lifu) who gave a ruling against them has fallen ill and is supposed to be taken to hospital in Europe.”
Galadima questioned the wisdom of such a reaction, arguing that the judge’s possible absence from Nigeria could create difficulties for the party in pursuing an appeal against the ruling.
According to him, the records of proceedings required for an appeal could not be signed by another judge if Lifu travelled outside the country, potentially delaying the party’s legal challenge until the judge returned.
“I just found out that maybe there aren’t intelligent people in the ADC,” he said, accusing some party members of failing to consider the possible legal consequences of the judge’s absence.
Galadima’s position, however, was an argument he advanced during the interview and should not be taken as an established legal determination of the procedures governing the preparation and certification of court records.
The controversy is connected to a November 5 judgment by Justice Lifu in a case challenging the leadership arrangements within the ADC.
The court set aside resolutions of the party’s 99th National Executive Committee meeting held on July 29, 2025, through which Senator David Mark and former Minister of Interior, Rauf Aregbesola, emerged as national officers.
The ruling also restrained the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) from recognising or dealing with the affected individuals as national officers of the party.
The judgment has created another legal and political challenge for the ADC as it prepares for the 2027 general elections, with the party indicating its intention to challenge the decision.
The dispute over the judge’s reported health condition has therefore become part of the wider political exchanges surrounding the court ruling and the opposition party’s efforts to defend its leadership structure.
Melaye’s response has now shifted attention to the specific comments attributed to him, with the former senator maintaining that he did not discuss the judge’s health.
While Galadima’s criticism was directed at what he considered an inappropriate reaction by some ADC members, Melaye’s denial makes clear that he rejects being identified as one of those who commented on or celebrated Lifu’s reported illness.
The disagreement has added another layer to the public exchanges among opposition political figures, even as the substantive dispute over the ADC leadership remains before the legal process.
