News Updates

Monday, 16 November, 2026

BREAKING NEWS 

Advertise With Us

ADC Accuses NBA of Double Standards Over Petition Against Lawyer Who Called Judge ‘Coconut Judge’


The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has accused the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) of applying double standards following its decision to petition the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) against lawyer Kalu Kalu over his description of Federal High Court judge, Justice Peter Lifu, as a “coconut judge”.

The opposition party questioned why the NBA moved against Kalu over his television comments but allegedly failed to demonstrate similar concern when the Court of Appeal previously criticised Justice Lifu over his handling of a separate case involving the deregistration of political parties.

The development has intensified the disagreement surrounding the November 5 judgment delivered by Justice Lifu, which invalidated the David Mark-led leadership of the ADC and actions taken under it.

In a statement issued on Saturday, November 14, the ADC’s National Publicity Secretary, Bolaji Abdullahi, warned the NBA against allowing itself to be drawn into what the party described as a political campaign against the opposition.

“The NBA is not a political party. It must, therefore, not be seen to be behaving like a member of a political coalition against the opposition,” Abdullahi said.

The party’s reaction followed the NBA’s announcement that its president, Oyinkansola Badejo-Okusanya, had forwarded a formal petition against Kalu to the LPDC, accompanied by the relevant broadcast recording.

Kalu, a lawyer associated with the ADC and former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar, made the controversial remark during an appearance on Channels Television’s Politics Today on November 11.

He was discussing the Federal High Court judgment concerning the ADC leadership dispute and its implications for Atiku’s 2027 presidential ambition.

During the programme, Kalu challenged interpretations suggesting that the judgment had automatically invalidated Atiku’s presidential candidacy, arguing that the court had nullified actions taken by the David Mark-led leadership from July 29, 2025.

While making his argument, the lawyer described Justice Lifu as a “coconut judge”, prompting the programme’s presenter, Seun Okinbaloye, to interrupt and caution him against making personal attacks on a sitting judicial officer.

Kalu subsequently withdrew the remark after the presenter challenged him.

NBA Defends Disciplinary Petition

Explaining its decision to petition the disciplinary committee, NBA President Badejo-Okusanya said lawyers were entitled to examine court judgments, challenge judicial reasoning and identify errors but must not resort to personal attacks against judges.

In a statement issued on November 13, she maintained that disagreement with a judicial decision did not excuse insulting the judge responsible for delivering it.

She cited the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners, 2023, which require lawyers to maintain professional standards and treat courts with respect, dignity and honour.

According to her, the NBA had forwarded the petition and relevant broadcast materials to the LPDC for consideration.

She, however, emphasised that the referral did not amount to a finding of professional misconduct against Kalu, who would be entitled to respond to the allegations.

The disciplinary committee, she said, would determine whether misconduct occurred and what sanction, if any, would be appropriate.

ADC Cites Previous Court of Appeal Ruling

Questioning the NBA’s position, the ADC referred to an earlier Court of Appeal decision involving Justice Lifu and the proposed deregistration of five political parties, including the ADC.

The party recalled that the appellate court had criticised the judge over a judgment ordering the deregistration of the parties despite an earlier appellate order staying proceedings.

The Court of Appeal subsequently overturned that judgment, holding that the Federal High Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit.

The ADC argued that the NBA’s response to Kalu’s remarks raised questions about the consistency of its position on accountability within the legal profession and the judiciary.

“What has Kalu Kalu said about Justice Peter Lifu that the Court of Appeal has not already said?” Abdullahi asked.

The party maintained that while lawyers should exercise restraint in their public statements, professional bodies must also demonstrate consistency when addressing issues involving judicial conduct.

It further warned that the NBA risked undermining public confidence in its neutrality if its actions were perceived as taking sides in the political dispute.

Disagreement Over Judicial Accountability

The controversy has brought renewed attention to the distinction between criticising judicial decisions and making personal remarks about judicial officers.

While the NBA maintains that lawyers can challenge judgments through legal arguments without insulting judges, the ADC insists that accountability within the judiciary should receive equal attention.

The two issues, however, concern separate proceedings: the Court of Appeal’s earlier decision on the proposed deregistration of political parties and Justice Lifu’s November 5 judgment concerning the ADC’s leadership dispute.

The NBA has maintained that judicial accountability and professional discipline are not mutually exclusive, arguing that lawyers must be held to professional standards while judges remain subject to appropriate accountability mechanisms.

As the disciplinary process awaits consideration by the LPDC, the committee is yet to determine whether Kalu’s remarks constitute professional misconduct.

0 comments on “ADC Accuses NBA of Double Standards Over Petition Against Lawyer Who Called Judge ‘Coconut Judge’”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories